Academic Certificates Acquired In Marriage Are Family Property – Court Rules

KEY POINTS

  • The judgment was issued by the Malawian high court on August 19, 2020, after a housewife named Telen Tewesa took her lecturer ex-husband, Chimwemwe Tewesa to court he sought a divorce after finishing his tertiary education.
  • Ellen wanted to determine whether the Bachelor’s degree and diploma could be distributed on a 50/50 basis.
  • Even though an educational degree, such as an MBA, lacks an exchange value or any objective transferable value on the open market, the Malawi High Court held that there is a property in the qualification.

A Malawi court made a landmark judgment likely to be used as a precedent around the world after ruling that academic qualifications obtained during the marriage are matrimonial property.

The judgment was issued by the Malawian high court on August 19, 2020, after a housewife named Telen Tewesa took her lecturer ex-husband, Chimwemwe Tewesa to court he sought a divorce after finishing his tertiary education.

the mother of four had been awarded a compensation of Malawi Krone 300,000 (Ksh 43,366) payable in 10 equal installments.

The court also ordered Chimwemwe to build a matrimonial house for Ellen or pay her in default Malawi Krone 150,000 (Ksh21,683).

Dissatisfied with the meager award, Ellen who has been married to Chimwemwe for 20 years, moved back to court for the division of the matrimonial property which according to her included her ex-husband’s academic qualifications obtained during the pendency of their marriage.

During the marriage, her husband acquired while they were married and progressed from a primary school teacher to a high school tutor and later became a college lecturer.

The court was faced with several issues including, whether academic degrees can be considered to be part of matrimonial property and whether there was marital property in the educational qualifications, namely a Bachelor of Education Humanities and Diploma in Education.

Ellen wanted to determine whether the Bachelor’s degree and diploma could be distributed on a 50/50 basis.

The court held that any person who pursued further education did it for the benefit of both himself and his family which includes his wife, children, and any other persons that stay with them during the subsistence of marriage.

Even though an educational degree, such as an MBA, lacks an exchange value or any objective transferable value on the open market, the Malawi High Court held that there is a property in the qualification.

Since the degree cannot be inherited, the court held that the future earning capacity and practicing licenses are marital property.

The rationale was that, with future earning capacity, the family and other beneficiaries would benefit from whatever could be realized by the degreed person so long as that person was alive and working for an income.

As for a practicing license, commonly given to doctors and lawyers, the court held that it forms part of the family property because when the owner dies, his practice could be inherited and continued by his family and friends.

On the case, the court also held that ignoring the contributions of the sacrificing spouse, who cooked for the husband, the four children, and doing some businesses just to top up the family budget, was an unfair advantage to the husband who had gained the education and degree without obligation. It held that the ex-husband would be granted unjust enrichment of the educated spouse.

READ MORE

The court determined that Ellen had a beneficial interest or equitable claim in her ex-husband’s educational qualifications as long as the marriage subsisted.

Since the marriage came to an end, Ellen would be compensated for her loss through the distribution of matrimonial property but her beneficial interest in his degrees duly comes to an end after the assets are shared fairly.

“At the dissolution of the marriage, the beneficial interest in the academic qualifications would manifest in that there would have been an order for the distribution of matrimonial property and maintenance of children. The property to be distributed was acquired through work which was obtained by using the educational qualifications of the respondent. The court considered the future earnings of the respondent in setting the amount of alimony then designated the alimony payments based on future income as property,” ruled the judge.

But on the issue of dividing said property in the academic degrees on a 50/50 basis was unrealistic.

“It ought to be borne in mind that the qualifications could not be physically divided between the couple and that a degree was regarded as property with only speculative value. It would be diametrically impractical to demand the respondent to also impart the knowledge he acquired while at college to the petitioner, but also that the names in the certificates could be interchanged from Chimwemwe S. Tewesa to Ellen Tewesa,” the court held.

Stay Connected
50,930FansLike
2,458FollowersFollow
61,453SubscribersSubscribe
Must Read
Related News