Home Court Controversial Ruling That Allows Wives To Claim Share Of Property Before Divorce

Controversial Ruling That Allows Wives To Claim Share Of Property Before Divorce

KEY POINTS:

  • A woman can seek her share of property from her husband without necessarily waiting for divorce.
  • The court can, however, not divide the matrimonial property until their marriage is dissolved.
  • The appeal stems from a dispute over properties worth more than Sh1.7 billion between Ann Kagure Kamau and Peter Kimani Wainaina.

- Advertisement -

A woman can seek her share of property from her husband without necessarily waiting for divorce.

The court can, however, not divide the matrimonial property until their marriage is dissolved.

In a landmark judgment which now gives a new twist on how properties acquired during a marriage are shared, Court of Appeal judges Mohamed Warsame, Patrick Kiage and Gatembu Kairu ruled that the law allows a spouse in a marriage to seek a declaration that a property is matrimonial.

“The above case demonstrates that a declaration under Section 17 of the Act is not necessarily pegged on the subsistence of a marriage. The effect of this section is that the court can make a declaration with regard to the suit property even though the parties are still married or pending divorce,” the judges ruled.

They continued: “It is our considered view that the High Court has jurisdiction to declare the rights of parties in relation to any matrimonial property which is contested.”

The appeal stems from a dispute over properties worth more than Sh1.7 billion between Ann Kagure Kamau and Peter Kimani Wainaina.

In her case, Kagure claimed that she married Kimani under Kikuyu customary law in 1999. According to the woman, their marriage hit the rocks and she filed for divorce and which was not yet settled.

She, however, asked the court to divide both properties and shares held by him at a ratio of 50:50.

On the other hand, Kimani denied that he was married to her. He urged the court to dismiss the matrimonial case as the issue of whether they were married was not settled. On the companies’ shares, he claimed they are separate entities and she ought to file a commercial case to lay her claim.

Family Court judge Margaret Muigai agreed with Kimani and struck out Kagure’s case.

Aggrieved, she moved to the appeal court arguing that the judge erred by throwing out her case.

She further asked the judges to restrict Kimani from dealing or transferring the properties and company shares until her case is determined.

READ MORE:

At the heart of the case are two prime properties in Kajiado and another in Nairobi. There are also shares held in Streetwise Media Services Limited, Springboard Holding Limited, Essential Mountain Links Limited, Upperhill Springs Restaurant Limited, Apollo Merchants Limited, Eight Investments Limited and Springboard Capital Limited.

Kagure urged the court to force Kimani to transfer 50 per cent of the shares held in the seven companies within 60 days of the judgment. She also sought to have all the money held in an escrow account under his name to also be divided equally.

In his reply, Kimani asserted that no marriage exists. He argued that she did not qualify to pursue him for matrimonial property until her marital status is determined.

However, the appeal court judges found the family Court judge judge erred by finding that the question of matrimonial property can only be settled after a divorce.

“It is our opinion that the divorce cause does not prevent a party from bringing an action for declaration of rights to property in the High Court under Section 17 of the Act,” they ruled.

- Advertisement -
- Advertisement -

Stay Connected

16,985FansLike
2,458FollowersFollow
61,453SubscribersSubscribe

Must Read

Biden Continues To Shatter Election Records As He Opens Huge 7 Million Vote Lead Over Trump

Joe Biden is soaring in popular vote as he has extended his margin over Donald Trump with a staggering 7 million votes.Biden had won...
- Advertisement -

US Supreme Court Petitioned To Block Joe Biden’s Win

Donald Trump lost all appeals to reverse Joe Biden's win in Pennsylvania in the state's courts, now the president wants to try his luck...

China Breaks US Monotony On The Moon As It Becomes Second Country To Plant Flag On Lunar Surface

China has become the second country in the world, after only United States, to plant its national flag on the moon.The pictures from China's...

Trump Raised Ksh 23 Billion To Challenge Biden’s Win in Court, And He’s Still Losing

President Donald Trump managed to raise $207.5 million to fund legal challenges to Democrat Joe Biden's victory.The money was raised by Trump’s campaign and...

Related News

Court Orders Mombasa Politician In Heroin Case To Issue New Security

Mombasa politician Maur Bwanamaka who is being protected for trafficking heroin worth Sh1.3 billion has been ordered by the court to produce new security. The...

Company Sues The Judiciary For Unfair Contract Termination

A firm that was tasked with refurbishing the High Court building in Nairobi is demanding the Judiciary to pay it over Sh500 million for...

Zimbabwe Revenue Authority Drop Fraud Case Against Ginimbi, Releases His Impounded Bentley And Rolls Royce

Genius ‘Ginimbi’ Kadungure's heir can now breathe a sigh of relief after Zimbabwe Revenue Authority dropped fraud case against the late businessman.The taxman initiated...

Nairobi Man Charged After Sodomizing Wife After Birth For 4 Months

A middle-aged man from Kangemi, Nairobi was on Thursday afternoon (December 3) charged with sodomizing his 43-year-old wifeThe suspect - Charles Mwaniki was arraigned...

Tob Cohen Family In A Vicious Fight With Widow Over 500M Home, Porsche, 2 Dogs

The family of murdered Dutch tycoon Tob Cohen is in a vicious battle with the widow Sarah Wairimu Kamotho seeking to get back a...